| 1 | Church of All SaintsTS9 6PS | Grade I |
| 2 | Ayton HallTS9 6PS | Grade II* |
| 3 | 10, Park Square (See Details for Further Address Information)TS9 6BP | Grade II |
| 4 | 10, Yarm Lane (See Details for Further Address Information)TS9 6PJ | Grade II |
| 5 | 11, 12 and 12a, High GreenTS9 6BJ | Grade II |
| 6 | 1,2 and 3, High GreenTS9 6BF | Grade II |
| 7 | 14-16, High GreenTS9 6BJ | Grade II |
| 8 | 25, Bridge Street (See Details for Further Address Information)TS9 6NP | Grade II |
| 9 | 2, Race Terrace (See Details for Further Address Information)TS9 6NS | Grade II |
| 10 | 39-43, Bridge StreetTS9 6NP | Grade II |
| 11 | 49, High Street (See Details for Further Address Information)TS9 6NJ | Grade II |
| 12 | 5, LevensideTS9 6NW | Grade II |
| 13 | 7, Low GreenTS9 6NN | Grade II |
| 14 | AcornTS9 6BF | Grade II |
| 15 | Archway CottageTS9 6NB | Grade II |
| 16 | Barclays BankTS9 6BW | Grade II |
| 17 | Beech GroveTS9 6NQ | Grade II |
| 18 | Captain Cook MemorialTS9 6NS | Grade II |
| 19 | Captain Cook's SchoolroomTS9 6NB | Grade II |
| 20 | Christ ChurchTS9 6AA | Grade II |
| 21 | Cook Headstone 2 Yards East of Church of All SaintsTS9 6NN | Grade II |
| 22 | Crown Cottage Marwood CottageTS9 6NH | Grade II |
| 23 | Entrance Gateway to South of Ayton HallTS9 6NN | Grade II |
| 24 | Farm Buildings to North of Ayton HallTS9 6PS | Grade II |
| 25 | Former Chapel in Grounds of Number 4 (Brookside)TS9 6NL | Grade II |
| 26 | Friends' School East Central BuildingTS9 6BF | Grade II |
| 27 | Friends' School West Central BuildingTS9 6SA | Grade II |
| 28 | Gate Piers and Garden Walls to Manor HouseTS9 6PT | Grade II |
| 29 | Gazebo to North West of Ayton HallTS9 6PS | Grade II |
| 30 | Great Ayton Quaker Meeting HouseTS9 6SA | Grade II |
| 31 | Hope CottageTS9 6BJ | Grade II |
| 32 | Ivy Cottage NutshellTS9 6BF | Grade II |
| 33 | K6 Telephone KioskTS9 6BW | Grade II |
| 34 | Langton House and Attached OutbuildingTS9 6NY | Grade II |
| 35 | Manor HouseTS9 6PT | Grade II |
| 36 | Marwoods Church of England School Number 6TS9 6NN | Grade II |
| 37 | Number 13 (Stonelea) and Number 15TS9 6HA | Grade II |
| 38 | Number 63 and Area WallTS9 6NQ | Grade II |
| 39 | Numbers 2, 4 and 6 with Adjoining Wall and OuthouseTS9 6NR | Grade II |
| 40 | Numbers 6 and 8 (Lodge to Friends' School) and Wall AttachedTS9 6SB | Grade II |
| 41 | Orchard HouseTS9 6BJ | Grade II |
| 42 | Outbuilding to East of Manor HouseTS9 6PT | Grade II |
| 43 | Police StationTS9 6AB | Grade II |
| 44 | Seaton HouseTS9 6HD | Grade II |
| 45 | The Royal Oak HotelTS9 6BW | Grade II |
| 46 | Wall, Gates, Piers and Fences to Churchyard of All SaintsTS9 6NN | Grade II |
| 47 | Wynford HouseTS9 6NH | Grade II |